CAP # 3 feedback

Grading and Comments
Student’s Name
Institutional Affiliation
Critically Appraised Paper Peer Rubric (CAP) – 100 points
Points
Title page with the focused clinical question Provided with all information
10 points Provided however not complete
5 points Not provided
0 points The critical question is provided. Running head is not numbered. There is an unnecessary spacing in the title (Pico Question)
8 Points
Clinical relevance statement Clear and concise clinical bottom line from both articles.
20 points Clinical bottom line reported however not clearly stated or lacking information
15 points Clinical bottom line not stated or not clear
10 points The article has a relevant clinical bottom line which emphasizes the effectiveness of sensory-based interventions while treating children with behavioral difficulties. The clinical relevance statement is clearly stated in the paper
20 Points
Study summary Comprehensive information provided in an article
30 points Most information provided on search—missing one-three items for comprehensive information
25 points Minimal information/detail on specific search
15 points The study covered vestibular, tactile and proprioceptive interventions of SBIs. The paper provides sufficient information regarding how occupational therapists can use SBIs to address behavioral disorders and improve functional performance.
28 points
Study appraisal Identification/statement of study strengths as well as threats to validities
25 points Partial statement of study strengths and limitations for both or one article incomplete
20 points Limited statement of study strength and/or threat in both articles
10 points The paper does not discuss the type of study design, level of evidence, study limitations, internal validity and an explanation of whether the results of the study can be generalized.

All this information had been provided in the article.
18 Points
Proper grammar, use of syntax and delivery of information Consistent use of proper grammar, spelling, syntax and clear delivery of information
10 points One-three errors in spelling, grammar, etc.
5 points More than three errors in spelling, syntax, and grammar
3 points Grammar and use of syntax are satisfactory. The information has been conveyed in a clear and concise way.
10 Points
Proper referencing format listed articles (APA or AMA)
Citations in the proper format
5 points More than two APA or format errors
3 points No citation formatting
1 point The paper has proper APA citation with a doi number. However, the citation should be indented.
4 Points
TOTAL 88 Points
Comments:
The article provides comprehensive information regarding the use of various sensory-based interventions. The information gathered shows that there are three types of intervention and they include tactile-based interventions, proprioceptive-based intervention, and vestibular-based intervention. Research shows that tactile-based interventions such as massage therapy can be more effective in addressing behavioral challenges as compared to the other two interventions.